Titration Indicator Choice

Which Indicator for Which Titration, and Why Phenolphthalein Is Wrong for Ammonia

An indicator is not a neutrality detector. It changes colour at its own pKa, which has nothing to do with where your equivalence point is, and the only question that matters is whether its two-unit colour change happens inside the vertical part of your titration curve. Choose the titration and the indicator and this page gives you the verdict, the reason, and which way the error runs when the pairing is wrong.

Does this indicator suit this titration?

Titration type, strength, concentration and indicator in, a verdict out
Name whichever is in the flask first and whichever is in the burette second; for the indicator question it makes no difference which way round you do it, because the equivalence pH is the same either way. Ethanoic acid with sodium hydroxide is the second option. Ammonia with hydrochloric acid is the third. Ethanoic acid with ammonia is the fourth, and it is the one that has no answer.
Ignored for a strong acid against a strong base, because then the equivalence point is exactly 7 whatever else is true. Ethanoic acid is pKa 4.76, methanoic 3.75, benzoic 4.20, hydrocyanic 9.21; ammonia is pKb 4.75, methylamine 3.36, aniline 9.40. For the weak-with-weak case this field is the pKa of the acid and the verdict does not depend on it, because the answer is the same whatever you put in.
Taken as the same for the flask and the burette, which is the usual school arrangement and makes the equivalence point land at equal volumes. It matters because the salt left at the equivalence point is diluted twofold by then, so the equivalence pH moves by half a unit for every hundredfold dilution — and because dilution shortens the vertical jump at both ends.
The ranges are conventional tabulated figures and published tables disagree with each other by up to 0.4 of a pH unit — the references below quote two sources that differ. Treat them as approximate: the real transition depends on the concentration of the indicator, on the lighting, and on whose eye is judging the colour. Litmus is in the list because it is the one everybody knows and the one that is almost never the right choice for a titration.
The shape of your titration, with the indicator's colour-change band laid across it. The horizontal shaded band is where this indicator changes colour; the green circle on the vertical dashed line is the equivalence point. The question the page answers is simply whether the circle is inside the band. Change the indicator and the band jumps up or down the pH scale; change the titration and the curve and the circle move instead. The curve is schematic in its volumes — the pH heights are computed, the horizontal spacing is not — because the point being made is about heights.
A good choice. The colour change happens inside the steep section, within about a drop of the equivalence pointExample

Ethanoic acid, pKa 4.76, at 0.100 mol/L titrated with 0.100 mol/L sodium hydroxide, using phenolphthalein

Advertisement
Advertisement

Every titration against every indicator on this page, at 0.1 mol/L

TitrationEquivalence pHMethyl orange 3.1-4.4Methyl red 4.4-6.2Bromothymol blue 6.0-7.6Phenolphthalein 8.3-10.0Litmus 5.0-8.0
Strong acid with strong base7.00Too earlyToo earlyGoodToo lateGood
Weak acid (pKa 4.76) with strong base8.73Too earlyToo earlyToo earlyGoodToo early
Weak base (pKb 4.75) with strong acid5.28Too lateGoodToo earlyToo lateGood
Weak acid with weak base7.00UselessUselessUselessUselessUseless
Produced by running every combination through this page. Three things are worth reading out of it. No indicator is good for more than two of the four rows, which is why the question has to be asked every time. Litmus looks good twice, but its range is three pH units wide and it changes colour gradually, so in practice it is a test for acidity rather than a titration indicator and no laboratory uses it as one — the verdict column cannot see that, and it is the one place where this page’s rule is too generous. And the bottom row is “useless” everywhere, not because the equivalence pH is awkward — it is 7.00, the easiest number on the table — but because there is no jump for any indicator to detect.

An indicator finds its own pKa, not your equivalence point

An indicator is a weak acid whose un-ionised form is one colour and whose anion is another. Phenolphthalein’s acid form is colourless and its anion is pink; methyl orange’s acid form is red and its anion yellow. Like any weak acid it has a pKa, and like any weak acid the ratio of its two forms is set by Henderson-Hasselbalch. When the pH is a unit below the indicator’s pKa the mixture is ten to one in favour of the acid form and the eye sees that colour; a unit above, it is ten to one the other way. So an indicator changes over roughly two pH units centred on its own pKa, and that is a property of the dye and of nothing else.

It follows that an indicator has no idea where your equivalence point is. It cannot detect neutrality, it cannot detect that the moles have balanced, and it does not go off at pH 7. It changes colour when the pH passes through its own window, whenever during your titration that happens to be. The job is to pick a dye whose window your titration crosses at the right moment.

That is possible only because the curve is nearly vertical near the equivalence point. Across one drop of titrant the pH of a strong acid titration moves more than five units, so any indicator with a window inside that range changes colour within a drop of the right volume. The mismatch in pH costs almost nothing in volume. Away from the vertical section the same two-unit window takes millilitres to cross, and the end point stops meaning anything.

So there are really two tests, and most textbooks only state the first. One: does the equivalence pH fall inside the indicator’s range? That is what this page checks. Two: is the curve steep enough there? That depends on how weak the acid is and how dilute everything is, and the titration curve page prints the size of the jump so you can check it. Below about 0.4 of a pH unit across a drop, the first test is irrelevant because no indicator will work at all.

The weak base against strong acid case is where everybody goes wrong, and it is worth being explicit about why. Students learn that phenolphthalein is “the” titration indicator, because the first titration they do is ethanoic acid with sodium hydroxide, where it is correct. Turn the titration round — ammonia in the flask, hydrochloric acid in the burette — and the salt left at equivalence is ammonium chloride. The ammonium ion is an acid, so the equivalence point is at pH 5.3, three units below where phenolphthalein even begins to react. Starting from alkaline, the solution is already pink; it goes colourless at about pH 8.3, which happens while most of the ammonia is still unreacted. The titre you record is far too small, and nothing about the colour change tells you so.

The weak-against-weak case has no answer at all, and that deserves saying plainly because exam questions ask it expecting the answer “none”. Both partners buffer, the curve rises smoothly through the equivalence point with no vertical section, and every indicator changes over several millilitres. The equivalence pH is a perfectly reasonable 7.0 for ethanoic acid against ammonia — the problem is not where the point is, it is that there is nothing sharp to find. A pH meter and the steepest point of the recorded curve is the only honest method.

Two practical notes the theory does not cover. Use two or three drops of indicator and no more: the indicator is itself a weak acid and a generous squirt consumes enough titrant to show up in the third significant figure. And titrate to the first permanent trace of the new colour rather than to a convincing one, comparing against an untitrated reference flask if you have one, because the eye is far better at comparing two colours than at judging one.

Where the equivalence pH itself comes from is the subject of the salt hydrolysis page; the pH of the weak acid before you start is on the weak acid and weak base pH page; and the flat stretch an indicator must avoid is the subject of the buffer capacity page.

Frequently asked questions

Why is phenolphthalein wrong for a weak base against a strong acid?

Because that titration ends acidic. The salt left at the equivalence point — ammonium chloride, for ammonia with hydrochloric acid — has a cation that hydrolyses, so the equivalence pH is around 5.3, not 7. Phenolphthalein does not change below pH 8.3, so its colour change happens while a large fraction of the base is still unreacted and the titre comes out far too small. Methyl red or methyl orange is the correct choice.

How do I choose an indicator for a titration?

Work out the equivalence pH, then pick an indicator whose transition range contains it, then check that the titration curve is steep enough there for the colour change to happen within a drop. Alkaline equivalence (weak acid, strong base) wants phenolphthalein; acidic equivalence (weak base, strong acid) wants methyl red or methyl orange; neutral equivalence (strong with strong) takes almost anything, with bromothymol blue the usual answer.

What is the difference between the end point and the equivalence point?

The equivalence point is defined by the chemistry: the volume at which the moles balance. The end point is defined by your eyes: the volume at which the indicator changed colour. They are never exactly equal, and the gap between them is the indicator error. A well-chosen indicator on a steep curve keeps the gap under a drop, which is smaller than you can read a burette to anyway.

Why can a weak acid not be titrated against a weak base?

Because neither end of the curve is steep. The weak acid buffers the first half of the titration and the weak base buffers the second half, so the pH drifts through the equivalence point instead of jumping across it, and an indicator changes colour over several millilitres. The equivalence pH itself is perfectly ordinary — about 7 when the pKa and pKb are similar — but there is no sharp transition to detect.

Why does the equivalence point of a weak acid titration come above pH 7?

Because what is left at the equivalence point is a salt whose anion is a base. The conjugate base of a weak acid takes a proton back from water, Kb = Kw/Ka, leaving hydroxide behind. For 0.05 mol/L sodium ethanoate the result is pH 8.73. The weaker the acid, the stronger its conjugate base, and the higher the equivalence point goes.

Does the concentration change which indicator I should use?

Yes, in two ways. It moves the equivalence pH of a weak system: half a unit for every hundredfold dilution, because the salt formula carries ½log10c. And, more seriously, it shortens the vertical jump at both ends, so an indicator that worked at 0.1 mol/L can miss at 0.001 mol/L even though the equivalence pH has barely moved. Dilute titrations need a pH meter sooner than most people expect.

How accurate are the transition ranges quoted here?

To about a few tenths of a pH unit, and no better. The two sources cited below give methyl orange as 3.1-4.4 and as 3.2-4.4, and methyl red as 4.4-6.2 and as 4.8-6.2. The range depends on how much indicator you add, on the lighting, and on the observer, because what is being judged is when a human eye notices one colour in the presence of another. Treat all of them as conventional tabulations rather than as measured constants.

Related calculators

References

  1. Chemistry LibreTexts, Acid-Base Indicators (Supplemental Modules, Physical and Theoretical Chemistry → Equilibria → Acid-Base Equilibria), read 14 November 2026. Gives litmus 5–8, methyl orange 3.1–4.4 and phenolphthalein 8.3–10.0, states the rule as “You have to choose an indicator which changes colour on the steep bit of the curve”, and says of the strong acid against weak base titration that “it is obvious that phenolphthalein would be completely useless”. That sentence is the whole of this batch’s indicator page in one line.
  2. Indicator data, pH courseware, Department of Chemistry, University of British Columbia (groups.chem.ubc.ca/courseware/pH/inddata.html), read 14 November 2026. Fifteen indicators with transition ranges: methyl orange 3.2–4.4, methyl red 4.8–6.2, bromothymol blue 6.0–7.6, phenolphthalein 8.2–10.0. The page cites no source of its own for the table, and its figures differ from the LibreTexts ones by up to 0.4 of a pH unit. That is why every indicator range on these pages is presented as a conventional tabulation rather than as a measurement: the ranges depend on the observer, the concentration of the indicator and the lighting, and published tables genuinely disagree.
  3. NCERT / CIET National MOOC e-text, Chemistry, Class XI, Equilibrium: Part 5 (module kech_10705, ciet.nic.in), read 14 November 2026. Its section 2, Hydrolysis of Salts and the pH of their Solutions, covers the three salt types and gives pH = 7 + ½(pKa − pKb) for the salt of a weak acid and a weak base; its section 3, Buffer Solutions, places the acetic acid / sodium acetate buffer near pH 4.75. The module quotes Ka = 1.8×10−5 for acetic acid (pKa 4.76) and Kb = 1.77×10−5 for aqueous ammonia, which are the default values on these pages.
  4. Annual Syllabus, Class XI, Chemistry (043), Session 2026-27, Directorate of Education, GNCT of Delhi (edustud.nic.in), read 14 November 2026. Unit 6, Equilibrium, lists “Ionic Equilibrium in Solution, Acids, Bases and Salts, Ionization of Acids and Bases, Buffer Solutions, Solubility Equilibria of Sparingly Soluble Salts”. This is a state directorate’s annual syllabus, not CBSE’s own curriculum document, which was not read for these pages; the unit numbering and the wording of the topic list follow the CBSE course but should be checked against whatever your own board publishes.