Reaction Quotient Q: Which Way Will It Shift
Reaction quotient Q against K: which way the reaction will run
Put the same fraction you use for K to a mixture that is NOT at equilibrium and you get Q. Compare the two and the direction follows with no further chemistry: below K it runs forward, above K it runs backward, equal and nothing moves. This page makes the comparison, including the case where they are equal.
Compare Q with K
a hydrogen–iodine mixture whose quotient Q is 10 against K = 49 for H₂ + I₂ ⇌ 2HI, with the one per cent tolerance chosen
One fraction, read twice
- Q
- the reaction quotient: the K expression evaluated with whatever amounts are in the vessel right now. Before anything has reacted it is usually 0; as the reaction runs forward it rises
- K
- the one value Q settles at. It depends on the equation as written and on the temperature, and on nothing else — not on how much you started with, not on the volume, not on a catalyst
- Q < K
- too little product for this constant, so the net reaction runs forward and Q rises to meet K
- Q > K
- too much product, so the net reaction runs backward and Q falls to meet K
- Q = K
- equilibrium, and a dynamic one: both reactions still run, at matched rates, so nothing changes on balance
Worked example
a hydrogen–iodine mixture whose quotient Q is 10 against K = 49 for H₂ + I₂ ⇌ 2HI, with the one per cent tolerance chosen
BUILD Q WITH THE K EXPRESSION, not a new one. For H2 + I2 ⇌ 2HI the expression is [HI]2/([H2][I2]). Put in the amounts in the vessel at this instant — say [HI] = 1.0, [H2] = [I2] = 0.3162 mol L−1 — and Q = 1.0 / 0.1 = 10. Nothing about this step knows or cares whether the mixture is at equilibrium
COMPARE WITH K, WHICH IS 49 FOR THIS EQUATION AT THIS TEMPERATURE. Q = 10 is below K = 49, so there is not enough product for this constant
CHECK THE TOLERANCE FIRST, because that is what the page does. One per cent of 49 is 0.49, and |10 − 49| = 39, which is far outside it. So this is not a near-miss at equilibrium
CHECK THE DISTANCE. Is K more than a hundred times Q? 49 is only 4.9 times 10, so no — this mixture is on the right side of the line but not remotely far from it. The verdict is the plain one: forward, to the right
AND SAY WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO Q. Running forward makes HI and consumes H2 and I2, so the top of the fraction grows and the bottom shrinks. Q climbs from 10, and it stops climbing at 49. Finding the amounts it stops at is the ICE table's job, not this page's
The same K, five different mixtures: Q decides, not the amounts
| Mixture at this moment | Q | Q against K = 49 | Net direction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pure reactants, no HI yet | 0 | far below | forward |
| [HI] = 1.0, [H₂] = [I₂] = 0.3162 | 10 | below | forward |
| [HI] = 1.4, [H₂] = [I₂] = 0.2 | 49 | equal | no net change |
| [HI] = 2.0, [H₂] = [I₂] = 0.1 | 400 | above | backward |
| Almost pure HI, traces of H₂ and I₂ | 100 000 | far above | backward |
Why the comparison works, and the two ways it is misused
Q and K are the same arithmetic done at two different moments. Write the fraction — products multiplied together with each amount raised to its coefficient, divided by the reactants treated the same way — and you can evaluate it whenever you like. Evaluate it on a settled mixture and the answer is K. Evaluate it on any other mixture and the answer is Q. That is the entire distinction, and it is why there is no second formula to learn here.
The direction then follows from arithmetic rather than from chemistry. Running the reaction forward puts more on the top of the fraction and less on the bottom, so Q rises; running it backward makes Q fall. A mixture whose Q is below K therefore moves forward, because forward is the direction in which Q grows towards K, and it keeps going until Q has arrived. This is worth internalising in place of the rule, because the rule is easy to remember backwards under exam pressure and the mechanism is not.
The first way it is misused is mixing units. A Q built from concentrations must be compared with Kc, and a Q built from partial pressures with Kp. The two constants can differ by thousands — the bridge between them is Kp = Kc(RT)Δn — so comparing a pressure quotient with a concentration constant gives a confident verdict that may well be the wrong way round. Convert one of them first.
The second is forgetting that K moves with temperature. Q is a property of the mixture; K is a property of the reaction at a stated temperature. Cool a settled mixture and nothing about the amounts changes, so Q does not move — but K does, and the mixture is suddenly on one side of the line without anybody having touched it. That is exactly why heating or cooling shifts an equilibrium when squeezing it may not: the Le Chatelier interpreter works through all five kinds of change, including the two that move nothing at all.
A last caution about what Q cannot tell you. It gives a direction and no speed. A mixture with Q far below K will run forward, and it may do so in a microsecond or over a geological age; nothing in this comparison distinguishes the two. Hydrogen and oxygen sitting in a jar have a Q enormously below the K for making water, and they sit there for years. The direction is thermodynamics; the rate is kinetics, and they are separate subjects that happen to share a chapter.
Frequently asked questions
What if Q and K come out exactly equal?
Then the mixture is at equilibrium and there is no net change — and this page says so, which is the main reason it carries a tolerance setting. With real measured numbers an exact match essentially never occurs, so a page that only tested greater than and less than would always announce a direction, however meaninglessly small the difference. Choose a tolerance of one or five per cent and the verdict becomes useful; choose the exact option when your Q and K came from a textbook and really are meant to be identical.
Can Q be bigger than K even though the reaction has not finished?
Yes, and it is common. Q above K simply means the mixture currently holds more product than this constant allows, which happens whenever somebody adds product, removes reactant, or makes the mixture at one temperature and observes it at another. The reaction then runs backward to fix it. There is nothing special about approaching equilibrium from the reactant side; a vessel of pure product reaches the same equilibrium travelling the other way.
Does a catalyst change Q or K?
Neither. A catalyst speeds up the forward and the reverse reaction by the same factor, so it changes how long the mixture takes to arrive and nothing about where it arrives. The NCERT text puts it flatly: a catalyst cannot alter the state of equilibrium. If your Q is below K, a catalyst will get you to K sooner and will not move K an inch closer.
My Q is zero. Is that allowed?
Yes, and this page gives it a verdict of its own. A mixture of pure reactants has no product in it, so the top of the fraction is zero and so is Q — which is below every possible K, so the reaction can only run forward. The mirror case, Q infinite, is not really available: it would need a mixture with literally no reactant left, which is not an equilibrium but a completed reaction, and the K box here will not accept zero for the same reason.
Related calculators
References
- NCERT, Chemistry Part I for class XI, the “Equilibrium” unit, read on 14 November 2026 as “Unit 07 Equilibrium Part-A” on the SATHEE service hosted by IIT Kanpur (sathee.iitk.ac.in), which republishes the NCERT text. This is the source of the relation these pages are built on: Kp = Kc(RT)Δn with Δn = np − nr counted over GASEOUS species only, and of the three consequences it states in words — Δn = 0 makes Kp = Kc, a positive Δn makes Kp larger than Kc, a negative Δn makes it smaller. The same text gives the units as (mol L−1)Δn for Kc and atm or bar to the Δn for Kp; defines the reaction quotient as the same ratio of products over reactants, each term raised to its stoichiometric coefficient, evaluated at any stage of the reaction; states Le Chatelier’s principle as a system at equilibrium responding to a change in concentration, pressure or temperature by shifting “in the direction that tends to undo the effect of the change”; says plainly that “a catalyst cannot alter the state of equilibrium” and only shortens the time taken to reach it; and tabulates no effect for a change made at constant volume, whatever the sign of Δn, which is the inert-gas case.
- W. R. Robinson and others, Chemistry 2e, OpenStax, section 13.2, “Equilibrium Constants”, revision of 14 February 2019 (read 14 November 2026). Read for the comparison with the Indian school treatment, and the two differ in a way worth knowing. OpenStax gives the Q against K rules in the same three cases — Q below K and the net reaction runs forward, Q above K and it runs in reverse, Q equal to K and the system is at equilibrium — but it assigns no units at all to Q or K, stating that the rigorous expressions use relative, dimensionless concentrations and pressures, and that disregarding units in an introductory course introduces only modest error. It also declines to put any numeric threshold on “large” or “small” K, saying only that a large K means most of the reactant has been converted by the time equilibrium is reached, and warning in the same section that K says nothing whatever about RATE: some of these equilibria arrive in milliseconds and some take years.
- COULD NOT BE READ, and nothing was substituted for any of it. The NCERT textbook PDFs on ncert.nic.in were not retrievable on 14 November 2026, which is why the NCERT text above is cited through the IIT Kanpur republication actually read rather than by textbook page number. A JoVE Science Education page on the small-x assumption returned an empty document. And one widely repeated rule is deliberately NOT sourced to a primary document here: the thresholds “K above 103 means products predominate, K below 10-3 means reactants predominate” appear in third-party restatements that attribute them to the NCERT equilibrium chapter, while OpenStax — which could be read in full — declines to put any number on it. These pages therefore present those two thresholds as a reading CONVENTION that many syllabuses teach, not as a measured or derived boundary, and the notes say which side of the convention a result falls on without claiming it is a law.
