Will This Redox Reaction Happen?
Will This Redox Reaction Happen?
A positive E°cell means a reaction is downhill. It does not mean it will happen in your lifetime. This page takes the two half-cell potentials, gives the thermodynamic verdict, and then asks the question most pages skip: is there a slow step? Aluminium should tear water apart and does not. That gap between feasible and fast is where the real answer lives.
Two potentials and one honest question about rate
A zinc rod dropped into silver nitrate solution. Ag⁺/Ag is reduced at +0.80 V; Zn²⁺/Zn is oxidised, tabulated at −0.76 V; no slow step is expected, because both are simple ions in solution.
Two questions, asked in order, and only the first one has a formula
- the thermodynamic question
- is E°cell positive? That is one subtraction, and it tells you the direction the reaction would go and how far. It is necessary and it is not sufficient
- the kinetic question
- how big is the activation energy of the slowest step? Nothing in the electrode-potential table carries this information. A reaction with ΔG° of −300 kJ/mol and an activation energy of 200 kJ/mol is spontaneous and invisible
- overpotential
- the extra voltage a real electrode needs beyond the thermodynamic value, almost always because a gas has to form. Water needs about 1.8 V to electrolyse against a predicted 1.23 V, and the difference is overpotential
- passivation
- an oxide film that forms faster than the reaction can proceed and then seals the surface. Aluminium, chromium, titanium and stainless steel all owe their usefulness to it, and all four look unreactive while their tabulated potentials say the opposite
- the water window
- roughly +0.82 V to −0.41 V at pH 7, and +1.23 V to 0.00 V at pH 0. A reagent outside it can react with the solvent, so the reaction you get may not be the reaction you wrote
Worked example
A zinc rod dropped into silver nitrate solution. Ag⁺/Ag is reduced at +0.80 V; Zn²⁺/Zn is oxidised, tabulated at −0.76 V; no slow step is expected, because both are simple ions in solution.
THE SUBTRACTION. E°cell = 0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V. Positive, so the reaction is thermodynamically downhill as written: zinc dissolves and silver plates out.
HOW FAR DOES IT GO? Two electrons move per zinc atom, so log10K = 2 × 1.56 / 0.0592 ≈ 52.7. That is an equilibrium constant of about 1052, which is complete by any standard you care to apply. No silver ion of any consequence survives.
NOW THE QUESTION THE TABLE CANNOT ANSWER. Is anything slow? Both half-reactions are simple ion-to-metal steps with no bonds to break and no gas to make, and the zinc surface is in direct contact with the solution. So no, and the verdict is feasible and fast.
AND IT IS. Drop zinc foil into silver nitrate and grey-white crystals of silver grow visibly on it within a few minutes, while the solution picks up nothing you can see, because zinc ions are colourless. This is the silver-tree demonstration.
CONTRAST IT WITH ALUMINIUM IN WATER. Al3+/Al sits at −1.66 V and water at about −0.83 V at pH 7, so E°cell is roughly +0.83 V and the reaction is comfortably favourable — more favourable, per electron, than a great many reactions that do happen. Choose the passivation option on this page with those numbers and the verdict changes to feasible but blocked, which is what a saucepan demonstrates every day.
THE RULE TO CARRY AWAY. A positive E°cell is permission, not a prediction. Thermodynamics tells you the reaction is allowed; only kinetics tells you it is happening.
The four kinds of slow step this page asks about
| Option | What is slow | Worked examples |
|---|---|---|
| No obvious barrier | nothing; electrons move between ions or between an ion and a metal surface with no bonds broken | Zn + Cu2+; Zn + 2Ag+; Fe3+ + I−. These go at once and are the reactions demonstrations are built from |
| A gas must form | atoms have to meet, bond and leave a surface, which costs an overpotential of several tenths of a volt on most electrode materials | electrolysis of water needing about 1.8 V against a predicted 1.23 V; acidified dichromate keeping in a bottle though it could oxidise water; the whole reason fuel cells need platinum |
| Many bonds, many electrons | the reaction cannot move five electrons at once, so it goes through intermediates and the slowest of them sets the rate | dilute HNO3, a strong oxidising agent that works unhurriedly; MnO4− titrations that need warming to start; SO42−, which is almost never reduced in a school reaction despite its tabulated potential |
| A surface layer is in the way | an oxide film forms faster than the reaction and then seals the metal off completely | aluminium in water and in air; chromium and stainless steel; titanium. Break the film and the predicted reaction starts immediately, which is what amalgamated aluminium demonstrates |
Can it happen, and will it? Two different questions
Feasibility in this topic means one thing only: is E°cell positive? Take the reduction potential of the species being reduced, subtract the reduction potential of the species being oxidised, and if the answer is positive then ΔG° is negative and the reaction is downhill. That is the whole of the thermodynamic test, and it is what every exam question on redox feasibility is asking for. The shortcut most students end up using amounts to the same thing: the species higher in the electrochemical series is the better oxidising agent, so it takes the electrons.
But downhill is not the same as moving. A ball at the top of a hill with a wall in front of it is still at the top of the hill. Thermodynamics tells you the depth of the valley; kinetics tells you the height of the wall; and nothing in a table of electrode potentials knows anything at all about the wall. This is why a page that answers “yes, E°cell is positive” and stops has told you only half the truth, and why this one asks about the slow step before it commits.
The standard example is aluminium. Al³⁺/Al is tabulated at −1.66 V, and water at pH 7 is reduced at about −0.83 V, so putting aluminium into water gives a cell potential of roughly +0.83 V. By the table, aluminium should fizz in water as vigorously as calcium does. It does not, and aluminium saucepans exist, because an oxide film two to three nanometres thick forms the instant a fresh surface meets air and seals the metal off. Amalgamate that surface with mercury so the film cannot form, and the aluminium reacts exactly as predicted. The thermodynamics was never wrong; it was never the whole story.
The second standard example is anything that has to make a gas. Water should electrolyse at 1.23 V. In a real cell it needs about 1.8 V, and the difference — the overpotential — is the price of persuading hydrogen and oxygen atoms to find each other, bond and leave the electrode. The same effect, running the other way, is why acidified dichromate and permanganate solutions keep in a bottle for years even though their tabulated potentials say they should be oxidising the water they are dissolved in. Slow is not the same as impossible, and a great deal of practical chemistry depends on the difference.
Reactions that move many electrons at once are a third case. Nothing moves five electrons in a single step, so a half-equation such as permanganate to manganese(II) has to proceed through a sequence of intermediates, and the slowest of them sets the pace. Dilute nitric acid is a powerful oxidising agent on paper and an unhurried one in practice; sulfate, despite a respectable tabulated potential, is almost never reduced in a school reaction at all. If your reaction involves a polyatomic oxoanion changing oxidation state substantially, expect to have to warm it.
And then there is the solvent. Water is only stable over a window of about 1.23 V at pH 0, or from +0.82 V to −0.41 V at pH 7. A reagent outside that window can react with the water instead of with what you intended, which is why fluorine is never used in aqueous solution and why sodium is extracted from a molten salt rather than from brine. The overpotentials above widen that window in practice, which is the only reason chlorine can be made by electrolysing brine at all when oxygen is thermodynamically easier to produce.
Using this page honestly. Put both potentials in as tabulated reduction potentials and let the page do the subtraction; do not flip a sign yourself. Then answer the kinetics question from what you know about the chemistry rather than from what you would like to be true. If you want the number rather than the verdict, the cell EMF page gives E°cell, ΔG° and K; if your conditions are not standard, the Nernst equation page moves the potential to where you actually are. One limitation to state plainly: this calculator cannot read a chemical equation, so it does not know which species you have in mind and cannot balance anything. It works entirely from the two numbers and the one judgement you give it.
Frequently asked questions
Does a positive E°cell guarantee the reaction happens?
No. It guarantees the reaction is thermodynamically downhill under standard conditions, which means it is allowed and, if it goes, it goes a long way. It says nothing about rate. Aluminium in water has a healthily positive cell potential and a saucepan does not dissolve.
What is an overpotential?
The extra voltage a real electrode needs on top of the thermodynamic value, almost always because a gas has to be formed. Electrolysing water needs about 1.8 V against a predicted 1.23 V. It is a kinetic effect, it depends strongly on the electrode material, and it is the reason chlorine rather than oxygen comes off a brine cell.
Why does aluminium not react with water?
It does, for a few nanometres, and then stops. The oxide formed is dense, adherent and insoluble, so it seals the surface. Remove the film — by amalgamating the metal, or in the presence of chloride, which attacks it — and the metal reacts as its potential predicts.
My reaction is feasible but nothing is happening. What do I do?
Warm it, use a catalyst, increase a concentration, or change the electrode material if it is an electrolysis. All four attack the activation energy rather than the thermodynamics. What will not help is rechecking the potentials, because they were never the problem.
What is the water window and why does it matter?
The range of potentials over which water itself is stable: roughly 0.00 V to +1.23 V at pH 0, and −0.41 V to +0.82 V at pH 7. A reagent outside it can oxidise or reduce the solvent, so the reaction you observe may not be the one you wrote. Overpotentials widen it in practice by several tenths of a volt in each direction.
Can this page tell me the products?
No. It has no way to read a chemical formula or balance an equation — the engine behind it handles numbers only. It takes two potentials and one judgement about rate and returns a verdict about the reaction you had in mind.
Related calculators
References
- Chemistry, Subject Code 043, Classes XI and XII (2026 to 2027), senior secondary curriculum, Central Board of Secondary Education, cbseacademic.nic.in (read 14 November 2026). Unit 2 of the Class XII course is Electrochemistry, carrying 9 of the 70 theory marks, and its topic list reads in full: “Electrochemical Cells, Galvanic Cells, Nernst Equation, Conductance of Electrolytic solutions, Electrolytic Cells and Electrolysis, Batteries, Fuel Cells, Corrosion.” What is not named there is worth as much as what is: the words Kohlrausch and Faraday appear nowhere in the Class XII unit text, although both are taught inside “Conductance of Electrolytic solutions” and “Electrolytic Cells and Electrolysis”. Quoted to establish what is in scope, not to claim any endorsement by the board.
- Cambridge International AS and A Level Chemistry 9701, syllabus for examination in 2025, 2026 and 2027, Cambridge Assessment International Education, cambridgeinternational.org (read 14 November 2026). Topic 24.2 asks candidates to “calculate a standard cell potential by combining two standard electrode potentials” and to “deduce the polarity of each electrode”, and Topic 24.1 asks for “the relationship F = Le between the Faraday constant, F, the Avogadro constant, L, and the charge on the electron, e” and for “the quantity of charge passed during electrolysis, using Q = It”. Two things in that syllabus are worth flagging because they make an identical question look different on two papers. It writes the Nernst equation as “E = E° + (0.059/z) log [oxidised species]/[reduced species]” — a PLUS sign, the ratio the other way up from the reaction quotient, and z where most Indian textbooks write n. And the phrase “cathode minus anode” does not appear in it at all; the subtraction is left as “combining” two potentials.
- Atkins’ Physical Chemistry, P. W. Atkins, J. de Paula and J. Keeler, Oxford University Press — the electrode-potential and Nernst material, the thermodynamic relation ΔG = −nFE, and the conductivity material in which the square-root dependence of molar conductivity on concentration is derived as a limiting law for strong electrolytes rather than as a general rule. Cited bibliographically: it is a printed textbook and no copy was retrieved during authoring, so it is named as the standard treatment and not quoted.
- Chemistry, Textbook for Class XII, Part I, National Council of Educational Research and Training, New Delhi — the Electrochemistry unit, which is where the standard-electrode-potential table, the Nernst equation, Faraday’s two laws of electrolysis and Kohlrausch’s law of independent migration of ions are set out for this syllabus. Cited bibliographically only: this source could not be read. ncert.nic.in serves its textbook PDFs under a robots policy that disallows automated retrieval, so nothing on this page is quoted from the chapter and no page or table number is claimed for it.
